A comparison of carbonic anhydrase among invertebrates, with a focus on cephalopods

Albert C Nyack, University of Rhode Island


This dissertation examined carbonic acid (CA) activity in gill and mantle muscle among several cephalopod species in terms of aerobic mass-specific metabolic rates (MR), evolutionary relationships, and environmental conditions. It also compared the protein-specific activity of CA in the respiratory tissue reported in the literature for a broad array of invertebrates. ^ The CA activity in gill and mantle muscle tissue from three squid species was measured to examine whether differences in activity may be related to phylogenetic relationships or environmental adaptations. The three squid species, Dosidicus gigas, Lolliguncula brevis, and Doryteuthis pealeii have similar MR but endure different physiological demands due to their respective environmental conditions. The largest member of family Ommastrephidae, Dosidicus gigas, undergoes diel vertical migrations into a well-defined oxygen minimum zone in the eastern Pacific. The brief squid, Lolliguncula brevis, is the only squid species that inhabits the wide-ranging abiotic conditions of estuarine waters. This species is in the same family as Doryteuthis pealeii , yet the latter requires narrower environmental parameters. For all three species the total CA activity was greater in gill tissue than in mantle muscle, but the activity in each tissue was statistically the same between these species. The distribution of CA isozymes within the subcellular compartments, however, was more similar between D. gigas and L. brevis, species that chronically endure variable conditions, than between more closely related L. brevis and D. pealeii. Reflecting the similar MR of these three species, total CA activity in gill scaled independent of both mass and MR, however there was a significant relationship in mantle muscle. The findings suggest that while total CA activity is reflective of whole organism, environmental conditions seem to affect the subcellular distribution of this enzyme. Additionally, it appears that the primary function of CA in cephalopod gills is towards the removal of the large amounts of CO2 produced in these muscular, highly active animals. ^ Broadening the comparison of CA activity among cephalopods, I examined the CA activity in gill and muscle tissue from cephalopod species at different depths to 1) further test the visual interaction hypothesis and 2) examine the relationship between CA activity and metabolic rate. The visual interactions hypothesis states that the decreasing metabolic rates with increasing depth distribution among visually-orienting oceanic species is due to relaxed selection for strong locomotory capacity because the diminished light levels result in less frequent predator-prey interactions. The CA activity in gills and gill mass each declined significantly with increasing depth. The protein concentration in both gill and mantle muscle also showed a significant decline with depth distribution. The CA activity in both gill and mantle muscle exhibited a strong, direct correlation with metabolic rates among cephalopods. These findings are in agreement with other studies that have tested the visual interactions hypothesis. Additionally, the activity of CA is clearly correlated with aerobic mass-specific metabolic rate among cephalopods. ^ To examine factors that affect CA activity once the influences of animal mass and metabolic rates are removed, I compared the protein-specific activity of CA in the respiratory tissues of 67 invertebrate species across four phyla. The data was obtained from published values of specific CA activity that met specific inclusion criteria. The specific CA activity values for all species sampled was analyzed in terms of taxonomic group, type of respiratory tissue, habitat, symbiotic relationships, and type of homogenate used in the assay. A subset of the data was utilized to examine residual correlations between specific CA activity and estimates of animal mass and metabolic rates. The weighted mean masses and metabolic rates within each family were calculated from values obtained through a second literature search. Using this truncated dataset only bivalves exhibited a correlation between specific CA activity and metabolic rate. The results suggest that, once difference in mass and MR are accounted for, the physiological demands placed on an organism to survive in a given habitat seem to be the driving factor underlying CA activity. (Abstract shortened by UMI.)^

Subject Area

Biology, Physiology|Environmental Sciences|Agriculture, Fisheries and Aquaculture

Recommended Citation

Albert C Nyack, "A comparison of carbonic anhydrase among invertebrates, with a focus on cephalopods" (2013). Dissertations and Master's Theses (Campus Access). Paper AAI3604662.